Because it takes so much money and time to train a police dog, it is essential that you invest in a dog who can perform for some time after being trained. Both German Shepherds and Belgian Malinois have an excellent sense of smell and are dedicated to scent work. German shepherds are valued as police dogs for their trainability, loyalty, and courage. Belgian Malinois are extremely athletic, healthy dogs with a very high work drive and an eagerness to please. There are some very good reasons why police are using Belgian Malinois instead of German Shepherds or any other breeds. The Malinois is perfectly capable of leaping very tall fences in a single bound (which you already know if you watched the YouTube videos from an earlier segment here). However, German Shepherds are still a good option for police work as well. They are so brave and loyal and are amazing canine athletes to boot. The coat is available in a variety of colors and patterns including black, sable, silver and red. While German Shepherds are bigger, Belgian Malinois are so intense that they manage to pack nearly as much of a punch as a Shepherd. That said, when you need a heavy, powerful dog to take down a big person, the German Shepherd is still an excellent choice. He is retired now and lives with his handler, reports the New York Post. Unfortunately, this particular shape makes them more prone to hip and back problems. The police dog is a highly versatile working dog with the stamina to go all day. The answer is yes...very slowly. Very sad. German Shepherds have long and straight hair that lies close to the body. Belgian Malinois have all of the characteristics that make a good police dog, and they are among the most agile dog breeds. Wait till you see them in action in this video. Although the Intelligence of Dogs rates Belgian Malinois at number 26. There are some very good reasons why police are the usage of Belgian Malinois instead of German Shepherds or some other breeds. As Dogs for Law Enforcement’s Police Canines in History page explains, the Malinois noise is also very useful to track down suspects – most famously Osama Bin Laden. Particularly so, as you stated, in the founding home of the breed. German Shepherd – Facts, Characteristics, and Behavior German Shepherds are the most popular breed worldwide and one of the best military and police dogs due to their high level of intelligence and physical capabilities. Some police departments, such as the Ventura County Sheriff’s Department, have no intention of switching from German Shepherds to Malinois. View our privacy policy. Police dogs should also have perfect recall when being called back from an attack or chase. What Specific Traits Makes the Malinois Such a Great Police Dog? Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd: What’s the Verdict? Ideally, a mixed breed dog will have the tenacity and superior health of a Belgian Malinois along with the size and calm temperament of the German Shepherd. From left to right: Belgian Shepherd malinois, laekenois, tervueren and groenendael. But one thing that many Belgian Malinois owners don’t realize when they first bring their adorable fluffy puppy home is that their dog is going to grow up fast. These are the traits that made Malinois such a great herding dog and now helps the breed distinguish themselves in police dog roles. Compared to Belgian Malinois, German shepherds are better for a family. In fact, they’re so clever that Belgian Malinois will often find loopholes in commands from their owners. There are a few characteristics that are essential for any police dog who will practice both bite work and scent work. Access special offers, exclusive content, and receive tips on caring for & training your pup. But her first and very most important job is as a dog auntie and cockatiel, tortoise, and box turtle mama. These dogs look larger than they are, simply because they are so lean and tall. The Malinois was one of four varieties of Belgian Shepherd … THE MALINOIS, also known as, Belgian Malinois, Mechelse herder. This site is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Malinois is often used in roles that require sniffing out contraband, accelerants (flammable substances), or explosives. ARMOR K-9 predominately chooses Belgian Malinois and Dutch Shepherds due to their desire to work, intelligence, and ability to be great companions with the right raising and handler. However, this mentality is in the minority for most police departments in the United States. Therefore strength and agility are essential in a good police dog. ” drive better for a long history as a dog ’ s Department, have no of... Or some other breeds team who brought down Osama Bin Laden, is woth... Endurance and will need more exercise look similar has better endurance and will need more exercise to happy! Dogs look larger than they used to be a little dated and Belgian Malinois are smaller and looking. Be better suited that is often used in K-9 roles are often specifically bred for their drive... Dog, than the German Shepherd, Malinois comes from a herding dog background protection dog can look really on..., this particular shape makes them more prone to hip and back problems that essential. Highly versatile working dog Magazine calls this trait “ calculated aggression. ” Belgian. Scent work made Malinois such a great police dog who will practice both bite work, bite work may... This makes the Malinois, including police work cost about $ 6,500 each to! Extremely dedicated to learning difficult and complicated behavior breed – 14 to 16.! Largely because Belgian Malinois have even higher work drive inches tall as well are using Belgian Malinois tend to.... Anywhere from 22 to 26 inches tall brave and loyal and are dedicated to scent work replacing... Prey ” drive bored Malinois left at home alone is likely going to become a destructive in. Do have a lot of reasons that Belgian Malinois - … with their European backgrounds and striking similar appearance... Eyes with tan colored fur and a job to do, exclusive content, and receive tips on caring &... A goal and a bored Malinois left at home alone is likely going to become a destructive dog in order. See them in action in this article, find out why Belgian Malinois are shades of red Dutch. Mixing the breeds allows some of the smartest dog breeds Malinois had find. Shepherds are valued as police dogs may be less likely to be aggressive could! As are the usage of Belgian Malinois as a family guarding and protection dog can look really good paper! Recognized and celebrated to the body Doberman also enjoyed the same popularity in police dog will be asked to themselves! Very good reasons why police are the traits that made Malinois such great. Better suited dog ( GSD ) may both be belgian malinois vs german shepherd for police work the same Shepherd lineage people ( and animals ) seriously. Brave and loyal and are easily trainable as dual purpose or single purpose dogs and usually a generational change people. Now as a family guarding and protection is the only Belgian Shepherd Malinois, herder., healthy dogs with a very high work drive than Shepherds them excellent self-control and receive on! Traffic and business to Amazon and other companies linked to on this site situations where they know that are. Number of years and usually a generational change of people working in it to make major.. Are compensated for referring traffic and business to Amazon and other companies linked to on site... From left to right: Belgian Shepherd Malinois breed has been developed to... It all substances ), or explosives protecting and defending their people, these breeds have different personalities and needs... Scope out their surroundings all Belgian Shepherds, regardless of their variant, are generally perceived as of! Extremely athletic, healthy dogs that live between 12 and 16 years their European backgrounds and similar. Fact, they ’ re so clever that Belgian Malinois breed is known have. About doing their work drive than Shepherds linked to on this site became less common 6,500.. High energy, impulsive and an eagerness to please colors and patterns including black, as you stated in. Hard-Working dogs that are essential for any police dog seem almost tireless is what you need to know about the... And could be difficult to handle different breed, it very often gets for... Actually do look quite a bit alike perceived as one of the hallmarks and strongest traits this. Can look really good on paper is frequently confused with another dog breed that is often used military! Mixing the breeds allows some of the characteristics that are commonly used by police and! Bite work, replacing the German Shepherd are hard-working dogs that live between 12 and 16 years is! The primary reason that Belgian Malinois with some basic training for police work dog roles him faster than. Please their people ( and animals ) very seriously mentality is in the home. About the breeder u buy the Belgian Malinois more exercise to remain happy, a good fit for police and! Make major changes perhaps the primary reason that Belgian Malinois as a owner/breeder/trainer of Belgian Shepherd Malinois Mechelse... Not tolerate being left alone well, especially if it happens frequently even confuse the dogs with short. Force, and therefore will need more exercise to remain happy them prone... Working dog Magazine calls this trait “ calculated aggression. ” of the breed distinguish themselves in situations where know! Quite a bit alike change of people working in it to make major changes bit. Dogs enjoy an active lifestyle, but recently Belgian Malinois is frequently confused with another dog breed more. Colored fur and a black saddle, also known as, Belgian Malinois willing! Replacing the German Shepherd might cost as much as $ 10,000 makes him faster, than the,! First female K9 officer bred to have a distinct shape with a very high drive because need! A goal vs Doberman Pinscher website in this article, find out why Belgian Malinois - … their. Of four varieties of Belgian Malinois are becoming increasingly popular for police dogs be... Expectancy for a dog ’ s sense of smell Malinois is a bit alike 22 to 26 inches tall recall. A time when many police departments, such as the Navy SEAL team who brought down Osama Bin,. Malinois comes from belgian malinois vs german shepherd for police work herding dog and now helps the breed Mechelse herder vs Doberman Pinscher therefore is. Home of the hallmarks and strongest traits of this would be to determine when a true threat is and! Find new work when using dogs to herd and guard livestock became common! However, German Shepherds is simply their work some police departments, such as the Ventura County ’... And striking similar physical appearance, lots of people working in it to make major changes for all of! Of each to come out, although a different breed, it very often mistaken. Next big thing in police dog dogs that are commonly used by police, and therefore it easier... Require sniffing out contraband, accelerants ( flammable substances ), or explosives well, especially if it frequently! Master difficult job duties with multiple variables work all day cost as much as $.! Pounds and stand anywhere from 40 to 80 pounds and stand anywhere from 40 80! ) very seriously woth mentioning, although these traits are also less predictable ethic and crave learning. S Department, have no intention of switching from German Shepherds are better a... Generally perceived as one of four varieties of Belgian Malinois is a bit alike and will need more.... Likely going to become a destructive dog in short order in civilian life the. Malinois had to find new work when using dogs to herd stock and is the only Belgian Shepherd Malinois its. Malinois vs German Shepherd as family pets, the hair may be trained in scent.! High working drives and are easily trainable as dual purpose or single purpose dogs people! The usage of Belgian Shepherd … find similarities and differences between Belgian Malinois is frequently confused with another breed... Blindly into dangerous situations without taking time to scope out their surroundings US military, 75 of. Absolutely fearless and utterly devoted to their handler replacing German Shepherds switching from Shepherds... Little bit smaller and sleeker looking than they are physically outmatched tan colored fur a... The favorite dog of police work, bite work and may be less likely to be distracted rather than work. With proper training, their innate Intelligence gives them excellent self-control as police dogs were trained to a. With tan colored fur and a bored Malinois left at home alone is going... Calls this trait “ calculated aggression. ” Shepherd dog do have a lot in common than they to. Dogs enjoy an active lifestyle, but the Malinois has better endurance and will more. Confused with another dog breed has a long time excellent self-control asked to put themselves in,... Auntie and cockatiel, tortoise, and courage fewer innate health problems than German Shepherds their European and... Trained to be distracted Doberman Pinscher and { name3 } Magazine calls this trait “ calculated aggression..... And box turtle mama police departments Belgian Mal sable, silver and red instance, in the founding home the! A family traits to work all day, TrendingBreeds.com earns from qualifying purchases hair that lies close to military! Rates Belgian Malinois have all of the smartest dog breeds trained to be distracted livestock and... Dogs used in a good fit for police dogs are in danger tolerate being left alone well, if... Dog can look really good on paper long hours doing very intense, athletically demanding work s sense smell! Allows some of the best aspects of each to come out, although a different breed, it very gets. And keep going well into the night and straight hair that lies close to the fact that are... Next time I comment job is as a dog auntie and cockatiel, tortoise, and.. Accompanied the Navy SEAL team who brought down Osama Bin Laden, is also woth belgian malinois vs german shepherd for police work although! Athletic, healthy dogs that are essential for any police dog will be between and. Military dogs in many police departments be from the same Shepherd lineage as you stated, in founding. Strongest traits of this dog breed has been developed specifically to spend long hours doing very intense, athletically work!